CB Podcast Ep. 103 – Top Ten Films of 2017

It’s finally here! The Cinema Bros present their top ten lists and recap their full top 20s. They also give out awards for best underrated performances and the best new directors of 2017.
Right Click and select “Save as…” to download.

Or choose your preferred listening app below.

Podcastaddict

Link Bank

Credits:

  • Hosts: Josiah Wampfler, Sam Wampfler & Jacob Wampfler
  • Produced by Josiah Wampfler
  • A Cinema Bros Network Podcast
  • Theme Music by Josiah Wampfler. Film clips used under fair use. All rights belong to their respective copyright holders
  • Music clips used under fair use. All rights belong to their respective copyright holders.
  • Visit our website for show notes as well as articles covering film, television, video games, music & more!
  • Email us at cinemabrospod@gmail.com

Joe’s Top Films of 2017: 20-11

By Josiah Wampfler


20. Gook

Directed by Justin Chon

Gook was a complete surprise that came out of nowhere. Starring Justin Chon, someone who I knew very little about, and directed by him as well, Gook is not only a great film, but a miracle and an inspiration. Made for pennies compared to most Hollywood productions (sub $100,000), Gook looks like it was made for several million dollars, is filled with wonderful performances and manages to authentically tackle an event from a point of view that we’ve never seen before. Telling the story of a wonderful friendship that crosses racial boundaries, Gook is set on the day the L.A. Riots broke out in 1992. As two Asian-American shoe store owners and a young black girl bond, we see a complexity to the issue of race and the city of Los Angeles that rarely gets shown in films.

One of Gook’s main selling points is how damn good it looks. Brilliantly captured in crisp black and white by cinematographer Ante Cheng (Who isn’t even out of film school yet), Gook, impressively, was one of the most visually stunning films I saw last year. It is not overly flashy with its camera movements, but when Cheng and Chon appropriately decide to get a bit more creative and artful in their composition, that is where the film truly shines.

What really anchors the film though are its performances and its wonderful story. Chon plays a man who took over his father’s shoe store when he died and is serious about running the place, but tortured by it. He did well casting himself in the role, because he is brilliant. David So plays his brother and brings an interesting counter point to Chon’s character as a man who knows he wants to get out of the shoe business by being an R&B Singer (An interestingly ludicrous dream). But, the performance that steals the show is from young Simone Baker as Kamilla, the young black girl who loves hanging out at the store. She is strong-willed, precocious and a delight to watch. She, along with her brother in the film (Curtiss Cook Jr.) are going to be two actors to watch in the coming years.

Gook is a triumph because it brings us a story that simply never gets told. It does not water-down the issue of race like so many films do, but presents us with a clear and realistic picture in all its messy complexity. The emotional core of the film is the friendship between Chon and Baker’s characters, but that is just what grounds all of the other interesting issues the film is dealing with. I’m so glad that this film was made and that I was able to watch it. It not only is Gook a wonderful film worth your time, but, as a filmmaker, it is also extremely inspiring. I can’t wait to see what all those involved do next.

Currently Available on VOD & Blu-ray/DVD

19. Good Time

Directed By The Safdie Brothers (Josh & Benny)

Robert Pattinson is a great actor. I unfortunately had not been paying much attention to his career after the Twilight films, but he clearly proves he has shed the vestiges of the sparkling vampires of those films with the Safdie Brothers’ Good Time. In a completely tranformative role, Pattinson plays a New York City criminal named Connie who decides to rob a bank with his developmentally disabled brother Nick. When the robbery goes awry, the brothers are separated and Nick is arrested and sent to Rikers Island. Nick will not be the last person harmed by being involved with Connie as the older brother searches for a way to get his brother out of jail, leaving a path of destruction behind him for anyone whom he meets.

Good Time is electric. It has a interesting 90s feel to it, with its incredible helicopter shots of Connie racing through the city and the incredibly vibrant neon lighting (And a great electronic score to boot). It has this unique beauty to it, yet New York City also reflects the grimy and grungy state of Connie’s soul. It is thrilling, but it takes time for the little moments to build character and a real emotional core to the film. The Safdie Brothers throughout the film are able to walk a tight line in many different ways. They make some quite poignant commentary on race and our criminal justice system throughout, are able to deliver on some truly surprising twists and turns and brilliantly handle the issue of Nick’s disability in a way that is respectful and truly unique. Though Ben Safdie, who plays Nick, is not developmentally disabled, his performance is not a characiture and by the end of the film we realize that the film is more Nick’s story than Connie’s.

Through a knockout performance from Pattinson that slowly reveals his Connie to be less anti-hero and more villain, Good Time delivers on the complexity it is after. It is a dark and disturbing thriller in all the right ways. I was unaware of the Safdie’s and fairly ignorant of Pattinson’s brilliance before this film, but now I can’t wait to watch more from them. Good Time is certainly just a taste of what is to come for these men.

Currently Available on VOD & Blu-ray/DVD

18. Lady Macbeth

Directed by William Oldroyd

Both empowering and revealing, Lady Macbeth is the perfect twist on the period drama. Under the careful direction of newcomer William Oldroyd, Lady Macbeth starts in a fairly familiar place making you believe that it may just be a traditional period drama. But, very quickly, we discover the darkness underneath the surface. Buoyed by an incredible lead performance by Florence Pugh as Lady Katherine Lester that feels like watching a major star be born, Lady Macbeth brilliantly shows the complexity of oppression and how quickly the oppressed can become the oppressor. It is a slow descent into the darkness of Katherine’s soul as she attempts to gain her freedom in an oppressive 1860s England. Unfortunately for those around her, she will stop at nothing to fulfill her own desires and she doesn’t care who she has to hurt in the process. With a devilishly entertaining performance from Pugh and the thought-provoking way the film deals with oppression and race, Lady Macbeth easily rises above the rest.

Read Full Review Here

Currently Available on VOD & Blu-ray/DVD

17. Strong Island

Directed by Yance Ford

Strong Island is such a striking film because, even though it revolves around a murder, it is not your typical crime documentary. In the film, first-time director Yance Ford investigates his brother’s murder, but we never see the killer’s face and his name is never spoken. When William Ford was shot and killed in 1992 by a white man, the case never even went to trial, and it has haunted the Ford family for years. Through extremely emotional and powerful interviews with his family and friends, Yance Ford explores the racial dynamics that led to the murder and the ultimate failure for the grand jury to indict. And though William’s case, we see parallels to more recent incidents of racial bias and the toll unjustified deaths like these take on families.

Strong Island, because it is so personal, hits home more than almost any other documentary I have seen. It is completely heartbreaking and incredibly revealing, really showing us the aftermath of a situation like this. It is as frustrating as reality, never giving us the answers and justice we desire. Yance Ford has crafted a visually unforgettable and incredibly emotional cry for justice for people of color in this country and the many families that have lost loved ones to racial violence. Hopefully, that cry will be heard.

Read Full Review Here

Currently streaming on Netflix

16. Dunkirk

Directed By Christopher Nolan

If Christopher Nolan hadn’t proven he was a complete master of the medium of cinema already, he certainly does so with Dunkirk. A visual feast and an insanely immersive experience, Nolan has crafted a surprisingly subversive war film in which our heroes are not the ones mowing down hundreds of people, but men just trying to survive. In Dunkirk, survival is its own type of heroism.

On every level Dunkirk is impressive. That starts with some wonderful performances from Tom Hardy, Mark Rylance and Fion Whitehead that really help to bring a good deal of emotion into the film. Nolan is able to completely immerse us in the experience of these characters, despite there being very little dialogue. That immersion is buoyed by all the other technical aspects of the film. Hans Zimmer’s incredible score completely melds with some of the best sound design I’ve ever heard in a war film. The score drives the entire movie forward, seemingly ascending upward infinitely and it uses and reacts to every explosion, gun shot, and footstep in the soundscape. All of this comes together with incredible visuals from Nolan and cinematographer Hoyte van Hoytema. I have only seen Dunkirk in 70mm IMAX and it is a film that makes the case loud and clear for the importance of the theatrical experience. Through great CGI and insane practical effects, Nolan is able to create incredibly authentic war scenes all captured on a gigantic canvas with a beautiful color palette. With Dunkirk, Nolan finally received his long-waited Best Director nomination from the Academy and damn… It is well deserved.

Currently Available on VOD & Blu-ray/DVD

15. mother!

Directed By Darren Aronofsky

Darren Aronofsky’s mother! is a film that is many things to many people. Interpretations of its meaning are myriad, as are reactions to its content. It is sad that it did not perform better in theaters because it was easily one of the best theatrical experiences I had last year. Part horror, part comedy and all batshit insanity, mother! is one of the most original films I have seen in years. Both in its plot and its presentation, Aronofsky has crafted a film that is maddeningly ambiguous and downright uncomfortable. I could not love him more for it.

Laughter is how I greeted the credits when they rolled on mother!. I wasn’t laughing at the film in a disparaging way, but because I needed to. Comedy comes from building up tension and anticipation that ends in a cathartic release. For two hours, Aronofsky builds that tension and the credits are his punchline. Much of that tension comes from one of the biggest horror aspects of the film, which is how damn uncomfortable it is. Through much of the film, people just keep on walking into the house and Jennifer Lawrence’s character is as confused and annoyed with them as the audience. These uninvited guests keep messing with her house and this affront to common courtesy feels as horrifying as any monster or demon in any other film. And besides the guests, the way Aronofsky chose to shoot the film is also a major part of what makes us feel unease. For much of the run time of the film we are in extremely tight closeup on Lawrence. So, not only are we connecting with her every feeling about all these people invading her space, but we also start to realize that we are invading her space as well.

The film is buoyed by some incredible performances as well. Javier Bardem is maddeningly likeable as a character we really want to hate. Michelle Pfeiffer delivers a deliciously catty and playfully devious performance. But, Lawrence is the one who sells the film. She gives what I believe is the best performance of her entire career in, easily, the strangest film she has ever done. She should have been nominated for all the awards for this one, because she is next-level incredible. From start to finish, Lawrence’s performance and Aronofsky’s intruding eye make mother! one hell of a ride. It is one of the most unique film experiences of last year and, I daresay, one of the most unique films of all time.

Currently Available on VOD & Blu-ray/DVD

14. I, Tonya

Directed By Craig Gillespie

I, Tonya doesn’t fit neatly into any categories. Neither a biopic, conventionally speaking, or a full-on comedy, the film smartly eschews most conventions and does its own thing (Much like its main character). From the very start, director Craig Gillespie makes clear that this is based on true events, but the truth of the matter is very much in question. Taken from various interviews, no one may ever truly know what happened leading up to the Tonya Harding/Nancy Kerrigan incident and I, Tonya is comfortable with that. That’s because Gillespie isn’t after the truth of the events, but a higher truth about how Tonya Harding became both the first American woman to land a triple axle jump and a woman accused of having a fellow competitor injured. All of this centers on a truly revelatory story of abuse.

Through a powerhouse performance from Margot Robbie, I, Tonya shows a surprisingly realistic portrait of the cyclical nature of abuse. From the abuse Harding receives at an early age from her mother (played by an incredible Allison Janney) to marrying the abusive Jeff Gillooly (An equally impressive Sebastian Stan), we see a presentation of abuse that is surprisingly able to use both comedic and dramatic elements. The use of comedy is respectfully restrained and does not minimize the abuse, but instead makes a line from Harding later on in the film cut even deeper. After we have seen the full extent of the abuse she endured, Harding addresses the audience directly, telling us that we were her abusers too. Through experiencing the rush to villainize and make fun of Harding in the media through her eyes, we see how true that statement really is. The film may take Harding’s side a little too much in regards to the truth of the actual incident, but it gets at a larger truth about celebrity and abuse that rings quite true.

I haven’t even gotten to the technical achievements of the film, but suffice to say I, Tonya presents this insane story in an incredibly engaging and visually dynamic way. If NBC filmed Olympic figure skating like I, Tonya does, I would watch every single second of coverage. The skating scenes (mainly accomplished through literally having a cameraman skate with Robbie and her doubles with a 35mm camera on his shoulder) are some of the most dynamic sports scenes I’ve ever seen. And editor Tatiana Riegel got an Oscar nomination for a reason. With wonderful performances, a tight script and an exciting visual presentation, I, Tonya is the rare biopic that feels like it brings something new to the equation.

Currently In Theaters

13. War for the Planet of the Apes

Directed By Matt Reeves

War for the Planet of the Apes is an astounding achievement in filmmaking and the best finale to a trilogy I’ve seen since Peter Jackson’s Return of the King. And much like that trilogy capper, War also features an astounding motion capture performance from the great Andy Serkis. Director Matt Reeves renders the world in lush colors and brings a type of controlled, sure-handed cinematography rarely seen in modern blockbusters. The action is electric, but not chaotic. It is a type of filmmaking and a type of story that we simply don’t see on this scale anymore where every single frame is deliberate and every camera move is purposeful. With War, Reeves has crafted a modern biblical epic with apes at its core and, though the filmmaking is clearly inspired by cinema of old, it couldn’t feel more fresh. With War, Matt Reeves has made the new Apes trilogy one of the best of all time.

Read Full Review Here

Currently Available on VOD & Blu-ray/DVD

12. BPM

Directed By Robin Campillo

There were only a handful of films that I cried during last year. There were only two I full-on ugly cried during: To The Bone and the French film BPM. Set in 1980s Paris during the height of the AIDS epidemic, BPM focuses on two men involved in a protest group fighting against the disease. The men, Sean and Nathan, fall in love and form a relationship despite their differing diagnoses (Sean has AIDS and Nathan does not). With incredibly engaging cinematography and wonderful performances from the two leads, BPM captures the hard work that political action requires and shows a loving, vibrant relationship between two gay men despite the complication of the disease. The film does not shy away from showing the joy that these two men experience together, thus making the inevitable darkness that comes for them all the more devastating. Most importantly though, the film pays tribute to the men and women who took a stand against corruption and indifference during a time when thousands of marginalized people were dying. It gives these braves souls their full humanity and tells their story to a world which, especially right now, could stand to hear it. BPM is not an easy film, but it is a vital, beautifully made story that needed to be told.

Read Full Review Here

Currently Available on VOD

11. First They Killed My Father

Directed By Angelina Jolie

First They Killed My Father was one of the most beautiful, devastating experiences I had with a film all year. Through the eyes of five year-old Loung Ung, it shows the horrors of the Cambodian genocide, the love of family, the tragedy of war, the beauty of Cambodia and the resilience of its people. Sareum Srey Moch as Loung gives one of the best child performances of the year and, because director Angelina Jolie cast the film locally, you can feel the authenticity from the rest of the cast as well. That it is also told entirely in the Khmer language adds to that.

Jolie herself was deserving of awards recognition for her direction. The way she captures the experience of this girl, literally putting the camera at her height and viewing the world as she would, it is incredibly immersive and strikingly beautiful. And her clear respect for the Cambodian people and this story shines through. With First They Killed My Father, Jolie and her crew managed to make a film that is not only engaging and technically impressive; They made a film that is important.

Read Full Review Here

Currently Streaming on Netflix

Honorable Mentions

 

For my Top 10 films of 2017, please listen to the Cinema Bros’ Top 10 Podcast HERE

Sam’s Top Films of 2017: 20-11

By Sam Wampfler


20. Three Billboards Outside Ebbing, Missouri

Directed by Martin McDonagh

Three Billboards may not be my favorite Martin McDonagh film, but I still felt that it had to make it onto my top 20. It is a wonderful piece of satire that delves right into so many societal issues that our world is facing, such as racism, sexism, and basic prejudice. It doesn’t handle all of these matters perfectly, but the mere fact that it is trying to comment on them sets it above many other films.

What really makes Three Billboards great are its fabulous performances. Frances McDormand, always fantastic, excels in her role as Mildred, a mother trying to get justice for her murdered child. She is downright hilarious in some scenes, especially when she is screaming in righteous anger at the idiots on the news covering her story, but it is in her moments of mourning her daughter that she obtains her most heartbreaking and poignant moments. Sam Rockwell is also notable as the racist cop who starts off as a problem for Mildred and ends up as her only supporter. He also spans the spectrum between hilarity and sadness, giving one of the best performances of his career. Three Billboards can be a rough watch at times, but it remains a relevant and entertaining film.

Currently In Theaters

19. Brigsby Bear

Directed By Dave McCary

Brigsby Bear was the last film I watched from 2017 and I am extremely glad I was able to fit it in. The plot of this film is super quirky as it deals with the uniquely millennial issue of pop culture addiction. No other generation has obsessed as much over different forms of media and this is expertly portrayed through James’ (SNL’s Kyle Mooney) love for his childhood TV show, Brigsby Bear. Mooney does a great job in his first big film acting role and really brings a heartwarming quality to the character.

Director Dave McCary’s greatest accomplishment in the film is creating the world of the Brigsby Bear show. We see clips from the original episodes of Brigsby Bear that are complete with a retro VHS effect. These clips are brilliant and have great voice acting moments by Mark Hamill. We then see James’ updated final episode of Brigsby Bear and it is a sight to behold. It contains some of the best shots of the entire film, including some paying homage to shows of the past including Star Wars and Star Trek. For his first feature film, McCary definitely created a lovely and visually entertaining tale.

Currently Available on VOD & Blu-ray/DVD

18. I, Tonya

Directed by Craig Gillespie

I, Tonya reminded me a lot of The Big Short. They have the same frenetic energy and they both tell a not so happy true story in a comedic and lighthearted way. I knew next to nothing about Tonya Harding before this film and I found the whole story completely fascinating. It took its source material, conflicting interviews, to heart and really showed all of the sides of the story without demonizing any of the characters.

What really makes this film work is the amazing performances by Margot Robbie and Allison Janney. Robbie was perfect for the role of Tonya Harding. She played Tonya during multiple stages in her life and she nailed every age perfectly. Janney, who plays Harding’s mother, completely transforms herself. Her performance is wonderful and you often find yourself laughing at many of her lines, even the terrible ones that you shouldn’t find funny. Her mother was a terrible person and Janney really leans into the role. The rest of the cast is great as well and they all help to make I, Tonya a truly delightful biopic.

Currently Available on VOD & Blu-ray/DVD

17. The Shape of Water

Directed by Guillermo del Toro

Guillermo del Toro has a knack for creating fantastical worlds that dazzle the minds of viewers. The world in The Shape of Water is no exception. On the surface it is merely a quaint 1960’s town, but, besides the fish man that we are introduced to, there is a particular sense of magic that the town exudes. It has a certain glow to it that makes you believe that anything could happen. This glow also seems to emanate from the main character Elisa (Sally Hawkins), a mute maid at a secret government facility. Hawkins plays Elisa brilliantly. She is absolutely charming and completely elevates an already incredible film.

Two of the most impressive technical aspects of The Shape of Water are the design of Doug Jones’ fish man and the underwater scenes. The makeup artists that created the fish man design and completely transformed Jones deserve much more credit than they have received. Jones himself is and always has been great at bringing his non-human parts to life in a very unique way, and the Shape of Water is no exception. Visually, the underwater scenes are phenomenal because most weren’t shot in water at all. It is uncanny how perfectly they captured how the character’s hair and clothes would flow underwater. The Shape of Water is definitely a technical and visual masterpiece.

Currently In Theaters

16. Blade Runner 2049

Directed By Dennis Villeneuve

Blade Runner 2049 is a long but film but it never feels long. Every shot and every scene is so enthralling, which is partially due to some amazing visual effects and production design and partially due to the terrific performances of an amazing cast. Ryan Gosling, as usual, gives a wonderful performance. It may even be one of the best of his career. Harrison Ford is also great, giving his signature grumpy old man performance, as he reprises his role as Rick Deckard.

The best aspect of the film, though, is how it not only continues the Blade Runner story but also updates it. It is the same world, but much has changed since the original. The most fascinating elements are the scenes where we see the cityscapes from the original now abandoned and surrounded by pollution. The society of the world has also changed, and not for the better, even though film’s antagonist would have you think so. Parallels can be made to our own world in this way. Blade Runner 2049 is not only a work of art, but also a great piece of social commentary.

Currently Available on VOD & Blu-ray/DVD

15. Thor: Ragnarok

Directed By Taika Waititi

It is rather astounding that it took three tries to get a good Thor film, but it finally happened. With Thor: Ragnarok, Taika Waititi gave us a funny, epic, and visually stunning comic book tale. One of his best moves was finally letting Chris Hemsworth unleash his comedic wit as the God of Thunder. Past films had him acting all grim and straight faced for much of their runtime. In Thor: Ragnarok he becomes one of the main driving comedic forces, along with Waititi’s ability to subvert audience expectation to a hilarious degree.

This is also one of the most visually stunning films that Marvel has released. Two scenes in particular stand out as exceptional. One is an homage to Willie Wonka and the Chocolate Factory, where in Thor is driven through a psychedelic tunnel, and the other is a flashback of Hela versus the Valkyries. The Valkyrie scene may be the most brilliant footage ever to come out of a comic book movie. Thor: Ragnarok is more proof that Marvel knows how to craft high quality entertaining films.

Currently Available on VOD & Blu-ray/DVD

14. Logan Lucky

Directed By Steven Soderbergh

 

Steven Soderbergh’s directing credits are somewhat all over the place. He has made dramas like Traffic, documentaries like Gray’s Anatomy, and more comedic fare like Magic Mike. For most mainstream moviegoers though he is best known for the Ocean’s Eleven series. With Logan Lucky he asks “What if they robbed NASCAR instead of Vegas?” It turns out that this was a question that had a hilarious answer.

Most notable for their comedic performances in the film are Adam Driver and Daniel Craig. Both of them transform themselves for their roles and give incredible performances. Besides being hilarious though, Logan Lucky also takes times to slow its pace and get in some very heartwarming character development. Some of this is between the two Logan brothers played by Driver and Channing Tatum, but the best example is the building of the relationship between Tatum’s character and his daughter. It is a running theme that he is not always around for her but the two care a great deal for each other. The opening scene is simply a conversation between father and daughter about their favorite country songs and the daughter’s upcoming pageant. It is a lovely moment and completely sets Logan Lucky a step above most traditional comedies.

Currently Available on VOD & Blu-ray/DVD

13. John Wick: Chapter 2

Directed By Chad Stahelski

The first John Wick was incredible in many ways. It had some of the most incredible action sequences ever put to film and Keanu Reeves as one of the most badass action stars of all time. It was hard to say if the second chapter would be able to live up to its predecessor, but it absolutely did in every way possible. The guns are bigger, the fights are more intense, and the cast includes some even bigger names, including Laurence Fishburne and Common (who gets in an epic physical brawl with Reeves).

John Wick Chapter 2’s most important addition is its world building. In the first film we are introduced to a hotel where no hits are allowed to go down. In this new chapter we find out there is a whole organization of hitmen with distinct rules, a weapon sommelier, and a group of phone operators all dressed in pink that are able to to put out hits with the touch of a button. In a sense we find out that this is a world that may be inhabited entirely by hitmen. It is a wonderful premise that really builds up a lot of excitement for the third chapter.

Currently Available on VOD & Blu-ray/DVD

12. Dunkirk

Directed By Christopher Nolan

Dunkirk is exceptional as a war film because, unlike others of its kind, it does not rely on a lot of normal war film tropes. There aren’t any sprawling battlefields. There are just soldiers on a beach. You barely even see the enemy forces. Dunkirk instead relies on its non-linear timeline, intense and driving score, and powerful performances to immerse the viewer in the experience of thousands of soldiers who were stranded in enemy territory waiting for what seemed like an almost impossible rescue.

Dunkirk’s non-linear timeline was confusing at first, but when it started to make sense it also became its most genius aspect. At this point, there have to have been hundreds of war films made and without a doubt Dunkirk is one of the most creative and moving of all of them. We get the stories of the men on the beach, the civilian boat owners, and the pilots trying to protect all of them at different yet interlocking speeds. All while a watch ticking effect accompanies the score and drives the action and the tension. It is truly one of Nolan’s most breathtaking achievements.

Currently Available on VOD & Blu-ray/DVD

11. Colossal

Directed By Nacho Vigalondo

Normally, films that involve giant monsters attacking cities don’t delve into any deep and emotional themes. Colossal goes against the norm and jumps straight into some very impressive commentary on addiction and abuse, both verbal and physical. Even with these dark themes, the film still remains funny, witty, and thoroughly enjoyable. Much of this is due to excellent performances by Anne Hathaway and Jason Sudeikis.

Hathaway, in particular, is extremely intriguing as the main character Gloria. She wholly transforms herself for the role and she is the main source of both the comedic and dramatic moments in the film. Her progression through the stages of addiction are hard to watch at times, but there is a unique charm to her performance that really make you feel for her. She also has some of the most hilarious moments when she discovers how she is linked to the monster in Seoul, South Korea. Colossal is a wonderful example of how you can take a common film genre and transform it into something meaningful, fun, and new.  

Currently Streaming on Hulu

 

For Sam’s Top 10 films of 2017, please listen to the Cinema Bros’ Top 10 Podcast HERE

“Lady Macbeth” – A Period Drama with a Dark, Twisted Edge

By Josiah Wampfler

“Look like the  innocent flower, but be the serpent under’t”

Lady Macbeth – Macbeth by William Shakespeare


Lady Macbeth may not be directly adapted from the famous Shakespeare play (It is an adaptation of the book Lady Macbeth of the Mtsenk District by Nikolai Leskov), but it takes this quote from Lady Macbeth herself to heart. Under the careful direction of newcomer William Oldroyd, Lady Macbeth starts in a fairly familiar place making you believe that it may just be a traditional period drama. But, very quickly, we discover the darkness underneath the surface. Our main character is not the innocent facade she puts forth to the world. Katherine Lester, like Lady Macbeth, is that serpent.

We enter Katherine’s (Florence Pugh) story as she is being married off to Alexander (Paul Hilton). It is soon clear though, that he is not interested in her and he harbors a great deal of disdain for her. On their first night together he orders her to disrobe, takes a long hard look at her and climbs into bed and falls asleep. It is here we start to see the hardship and even the boredom faced by a woman in 1860s England. Katherine’s father-in-law, Boris (Christopher Fairbank), tells her to her face that he considers her no more than property; a means to an end; a way for his son to produce an heir. She is then understandably relieved when she finds out that Alexander and Boris will be leaving for an extended period of time and she will have the house to herself.

This is where Pugh truly begins to shine. I felt while watching Lady Macbeth like I was watching Jennifer Lawrence in Winter’s Bone; Like I was watching a star be born. Here where we start to see “the serpent under’t”, but Oldroyd smartly also gives us a reason to root for Katherine. We see her finally escape the house that has been her prison to walk the beautiful England countryside and we bond with her in her delight. But then, things get complicated as Katherine begins an affair with one of her husband’s workers, Sebastian (Cosmo Jarvis). As Katherine and Sebastian fulfill their desires together, we see her liberated, but we sense something sinister underneath. When Boris finally returns, that sinister serpent reveals itself as she shows that she will stop at nothing to keep her newfound freedom and she doesn’t care who she has to hurt in the process.

Chief among those harmed by Katherine’s ruthlessness is Ana (Naomi Ackie), a black woman who serves as her main housemaid. With Ana’s character, Oldroyd brilliantly shows the complexity of oppression. Katherine treats Ana much the same as the men in her life treat her: with disdain. She shows no appreciation for the work that Ana does and even her affair with Sebastian is a slight to Ana as Katherine first meets him when she find him and the other workers harassing Ana. Eventually Katherine quite literally bullies Ana into silence when she involves her in her devilish schemes. Through this, Oldroyd shows us how, in an oppressive society, the oppressed can quickly become the oppressor.

Lady Macbeth is a slow descent into darkness and that descent is carried brilliantly by Pugh’s performance and Oldroyd’s patient, steady camera. Pugh is very careful not to show us who the true Katherine is for much of the film. Even in the most intimate of moments, there is facade. The brilliance of the performance is how Pugh doles out those little moments of truth. Every cold glance or icy stare warns us about what is to come and Pugh sells each one masterfully.

Both empowering and revealing, Lady Macbeth is the perfect twist on the period drama. The devilishly entertaining performance from Pugh and the thought-provoking way the film deals with oppression and race make Lady Macbeth easily rise above the rest. Oldroyd and Pugh have certainly made their mark and I can’t wait to see what they do next.

CB Podcast Ep. 81 – “Dunkirk” Review

This week, the bros present Trailpocalypse Now as they break down 10 trailers that dropped recently and review Christopher Nolan’s latest, “Dunkirk”.
Right Click and select “Save as…” to download.

Or choose your preferred listening app below.

Podcastaddict

Link Bank

Credits:
  • Hosts: Josiah Wampfler, Sam Wampfler & Jake Wampfler
  • Produced by Josiah Wampfler
  • A Cinema Bros Network Podcast
  • Theme Music by Josiah Wampfler. Film clips used under fair use. All rights belong to their respective copyright holders
  • Music clips used under fair use. All rights belong to their respective copyright holders.
  • Visit our website for show notes as well as articles covering film, television, video games, music & more!
  • Email us at cinemabrospod@gmail.com

CB Podcast Ep. 76 – “It Comes At Night” Review

This week, the bros bring you some film news, discuss some recently released trailers and review up-and-coming director Trey Edward Shults’ new film, “It Comes At Night”.
Right Click and select “Save as…” to download.

Or choose your preferred listening app below.

Podcastaddict

Link Bank

Credits:
  • Hosts: Josiah Wampfler, Sam Wampfler & Jake Wampfler
  • Produced by Josiah Wampfler
  • A Cinema Bros Network Podcast
  • Theme Music by Josiah Wampfler. Film clips used under fair use. All rights belong to their respective copyright holders
  • Music clips used under fair use. All rights belong to their respective copyright holders.
  • Visit our website for show notes as well as articles covering film, television, video games, music & more!
  • Email us at cinemabrospod@gmail.com

CB Podcast Ep. 31 – “Jungle Book” Review

This week on the podcast, the bros discuss film news, preview season 6 of ‘Game of Thrones’ and review the newest adaptation of the Disney classic, ‘The Jungle Book.’

Right Click and select “Save as…” to download.

Or choose your preferred listening app below.

Podcastaddict

Link Bank

Your Superman is Dead. Get Over it.

By Josiah Wampfler

“Truth. Justice. The American way.” These are the qualities that represent Superman to many people. Since 1938, the character has been known as the pinnacle of heroism and his name has been synonymous with hope and optimism in popular culture. But today, we have a different Superman. This Superman exists in a world not unlike our own, where cynicism is common and acts of heroism are not always met with praise. This Superman is a man who is not entirely sure what being a hero means or whether the world actually needs him to be one. And it is this Superman, according to critics like Devin Faraci at Birth.Movies.Death, that spells the end of an American icon. And it is Zach Snyder who killed him.

In his article, “Superman and the Damage Done: A Requiem for an American Icon,” Faraci claims that Snyder’s “ugly new interpretation” of the character in both Man of Steel and Batman v. Superman: Dawn of Justice “devalues the simple heroism of Superman and turns the decent, graceful character into a mean, nasty force of brutish strength.”

This view has not been uncommon in the days since Batman v. Superman released. I have heard people say that the film “got the character of Superman wrong,” that the film “isn’t what superhero films are supposed to be” or that Snyder “deeply misunderstands” the character of Superman. The film has been ravaged by critics, and while many of the criticisms are valid – the film certainly has an array of problems – I find this particular criticism to be quite dubious. Zach Snyder does not “deeply misunderstand” the character of Superman. It is those that are saying this that “deeply misunderstand” Snyder’s vision for the character.

The complaints with this Superman began back when Man of Steel came out. Critics of the film decried this new Superman who was unsure if he should be a hero, caused massive destruction to the world in his fight with General Zod and executed Zod by snapping his neck. While Snyder having Clark let his father die is still inexcusable, everything else made sense. Superman’s reluctance to be a hero was an interesting dimension to a usually flat character, the massive destruction caused makes sense in a battle between two super-men and Superman had no choice but to kill Zod.

The same critics that leveled these complaints against Man of Steel are the ones saying that Zach Snyder has officially killed the character in Batman v. Superman. The great irony of it all is that Snyder gave critics exactly what they wanted: consequences. While Man of Steel seemed to overlook the destruction caused by Superman, Batman v. Superman dwells on that destruction and gives weight to that destruction. This is because the new film is mostly told from Batman’s perspective – easily the biggest critic of Superman.

Yes, this Superman is not the do-good Boy Scout that Christopher Reeves’ version was. Yes, we are compelled to mistrust the Man of Steel in this film. We don’t particularly like the character through most of the film because this is not a Superman film. It is a Batman film (hence why his name is first in the title).

Granted, the film does not always do the greatest job of keeping with Batman’s perspective and that is one of its many problems. But, one only needs to look a little closer and it is quite clear that this is the case. Man of Steel seems almost overly optimistic compared to the darkness in Batman v. Superman because Batman is an overly cynical character. This overly cynical Batman would seem pretty crazy if the Superman he wanted to kill was the same as Christopher Reeves’ Superman. We would hate Batman, and it is very important that we are sympathetic to Batman in this film.

The other aspect of Snyder’s Superman that critics get wrong is the overall themes he is working with. Devin Faraci writes in his article, “One of the larger themes of Batman v. Superman: Dawn of Justice is the idea that every act of heroism is a catalyst for something terrible in the world, a point of view that is not only a) insane but b) inherently anti-Superman.” He goes on to call this theme “intrinsically nihilistic.”

This is another example of how critics are fundamentally misreading the film. Again, Snyder’s themes sometimes get a bit muddled, but they are quite clear if only you look a little deeper.

The theme of the film is not that every heroic action will lead to something terrible, but that every heroic action could lead to unintended harm. The film is not saying Superman shouldn’t be a hero, it is saying that he should think more about the consequences his actions have on the world around him.

You can draw a direct correlation between the debate the film has over Superman and the debate we as a country have had over our foreign policy and specifically our drone program. When we call a drone strike, we may kill a terrorist leader, but there is also the chance of civilian casualties. Just as we must consider the effects of a drone strike, so too must Superman consider the effects of his actions. As another comic book company’s character said, “With great power comes great responsibility.”

Also, so what if this version of Superman is a bit nihilistic? Sometimes nihilistic, dark storytelling is more appealing because I think we like to wallow a bit in the darkness of life every once in a while. Sometimes these stories are just more interesting than the glossy, hopeful stories of past Superman films. This is probably why Batman is a much more popular and beloved character, despite him being far more cynical. Maybe, we all have a bit of nihilist in us.

tumblr_n56rrk0g291slgex0o1_500

Still, some critics proclaim that Batman v. Superman is not what superhero films are “supposed to be.” They say that superheroes are meant to be beacons of hope for us to look to; that superheroes are meant to inspire us.  They long for the days of Christopher Reeve, where seeing Superman on-screen was a way to escape the darkness of life.

While I certainly love the Marvel brand of superhero films that are bright and hopeful and Christopher Reeves’ Superman was the first great superhero film, I like that DC has decided to bring something different to the table now. They don’t want us to escape the darkness of life. They want us to really think about it.

The last line of Devin Faraci’s article states, “I feel bad for the youngest generation who has been handed a jar of granny’s peach tea instead of truth, justice and the American way.”

Maybe, Faraci, without even knowing it, just stated exactly what this film is trying to say. That, by flipping this American icon on his head, by making us question the man whose slogan is “Truth, Justice and the American Way,” Snyder is saying what a lot of younger people are feeling today: That the American dream we were taught would be there for us is no more…and in its place is a lonely jar of granny’s peach tea.